lvt vs tile Poulsbo, WA, and Lakewood, WA

Luxury Vinyl vs. Tile: Comparing Durability, Style, and Maintenance

Choosing the right flooring sets the foundation for any room. Two popular choices—luxury vinyl tile (LVT) and ceramic/porcelain tile in Lakewood and Poulsbo, WA—each offer distinct advantages. Before embarking on your flooring project, let's explore these options to help you make an informed decision. When you’re ready, don’t hesitate to give Emerald Installation a call to learn more about our LVT or our tile selection. 

What’s the distinction between luxury vinyl tile and tile? 

What is luxury vinyl tile? 

Luxury vinyl tile (LVT) is a type of resilient flooring engineered to mimic the look of natural materials like wood, stone, or ceramic tile. It is made of multiple layers: 

  • Base Layer: provides stability and support
  • Design Layer: A high-definition printed image that gives LVT its realistic appearance.
  • Wear Layer: A tough, transparent coating that protects the design from scratches, stains, and fading.
  • Optional Topcoat: Some LVT has an additional protective layer for even greater durability.

If you want the beautiful look of natural materials alongside practicality and affordability, then luxury vinyl tile could be a perfect fit for your home.

What is tile? 

Tile is a thin, durable piece of material used for covering roofs, floors, walls, and other surfaces. Tiles offer a combination of functionality and aesthetic appeal.

Common Types of Tile:

  • Ceramic Tile: Made from clay that is fired in a kiln. Ceramic tile is popular for its durability, water resistance, and wide array of colors, patterns, and finishes.
  • Porcelain Tile: A denser and more durable type of ceramic tile. Excellent for both indoor and outdoor use due to its high resistance to scratching, staining, and water.
  • Natural Stone Tile: Cut from natural stone like marble, granite, slate, or travertine. Each piece is unique and offers timeless beauty, though natural stone generally requires more maintenance than ceramic/porcelain.
  • Glass Tile: Prized for its decorative allure and ability to reflect light. Often used for backsplashes or as accent pieces.

Finding the perfect flooring for your Washington home - is it LVT vs tile?



This flooring is known for its resilience. It resists scratches, dents, and stains remarkably well. Plus, it's completely waterproof, making it ideal for high-traffic areas, moisture-prone rooms like kitchens and bathrooms, or homes with pets and children.

Ceramic/Porcelain Tile: 

Tile is famed for its supreme durability. It's incredibly hard and resists scratching even under heavy use. While it does well with water resistance, it can be prone to chipping or cracking if a heavy object is dropped directly onto it.

The Verdict*: 

Both options offer long-lasting flooring solutions. LVT is a bit more forgiving in terms of impacts, while tile wins slightly with scratch resistance.

LVT vs tile style: which one fits your ideal look? 


Modern technology gives LVT a remarkable edge. It realistically mimics the look of natural materials like wood, stone, and even concrete. The variety of styles, colors, and textures is virtually limitless.

Tile offers classic beauty with an abundance of options. From timeless marble to intricate mosaics, tile lets you express your unique design preferences. Glazes allow for endless color choices as well.

The Verdict:

It's truly a tie! LVT may have slightly more design flexibility, but tile's timeless appeal is hard to beat. The decision comes down to your personal aesthetic preference.

Which one is easier to maintain? 


This low-maintenance star is a breeze to keep clean. Regular sweeping and mopping with a suitable cleaner is usually all it takes.


Tiles themselves are easy to clean, but grout lines require more attention. Sealing your grout helps prevent staining, but some periodic scrubbing may be needed to maintain its bright appearance.

The Verdict

LVT wins here for its hassle-free, low-maintenance qualities.

Additional considerations when deciding between luxury vinyl tile vs tile

  • Comfort: Tile feels hard and cold underfoot. LVT offers a touch more warmth and give.
  • Installation: Tile installation is more labor-intensive and often best left to professionals. DIYers may find LVT a more manageable project.
  • Cost: LVT is typically more budget-friendly than ceramic or porcelain tile.

3 Popular FAQs about tile and luxury vinyl tile floors

Question: Can I install LVT or tile over an existing floor?

Answer: LVT can sometimes be installed over other flooring with proper preparation. Tile requires a very solid, level subfloor.

Question: Are both options good for radiant floor heating?

Answer: Yes, both LVT and tile conduct heat well, making them excellent choices for heated floors.

Question: Does either flooring type increase resale value? 

Answer: Both high-quality LVT and tile can boost resale value, but tile may have a slight edge due to its reputation for longevity.

Still unsure? Stop in and experience these two popular flooring materials for yourself

If you're considering new flooring in the Poulsbo, WA, Lakewood, WA, Kitsap County, WA, Pierce County, WA, or King County, WA, or neighboring Washington areas, getting tailored advice is invaluable. Visit the experts at Emerald Installation, a locally trusted flooring store with over 25 years of experience. We’ll help you navigate the wide world of flooring options to find the perfect fit for your home.